Expense Reimbursement: Accountable Plans and State Rules
You can reimburse business expenses tax free only through an IRS accountable plan: the expense must be business related, substantiated within a reasonable period, and any excess returned. Everything else is taxable wages. Separately, states such as California, Illinois, Iowa and New Hampshire require reimbursement, and the FLSA bars required costs that push pay below minimum wage.
This guide is for payroll and HR teams setting or fixing an expense policy, especially for field staff and remote employees.
Key takeaways
- An accountable plan needs three things: a business connection, substantiation within a reasonable period, and return of any excess.
- The IRS business standard mileage rate for 2026 is 72.5 cents per mile.
- Payments under a nonaccountable plan, such as a flat car allowance, are wages subject to income tax withholding, Social Security, Medicare and FUTA.
- Federal tax rules say how to treat a reimbursement. State labor laws decide whether you owe one at all.
- Under the FLSA, unreimbursed required costs that cut into minimum wage are treated as an illegal kickback.
What makes an expense plan "accountable" under IRS rules?
The IRS spells out the test in Publication 15 (Circular E) for employers and in Publication 463 for travel, gift and car expenses. Your arrangement must require all three of these:
- Business connection. The employee paid or incurred allowable expenses while working for you, and the payment isn't money they'd have received as wages anyway.
- Substantiation. The employee accounts for the expense (amount, date, place, business purpose) within a reasonable period.
- Return of excess. The employee returns anything above substantiated expenses within a reasonable period.
Publication 15 says amounts paid under an accountable plan aren't wages and aren't subject to income tax, Social Security, Medicare or FUTA. If an employee doesn't substantiate or return the excess, that excess is treated as paid under a nonaccountable plan and becomes taxable in the first payroll period after the reasonable period ends.
What counts as a "reasonable period"?
Publication 463 lists timelines the IRS will always treat as reasonable, whatever the circumstances:
| Action | Safe harbor timing |
|---|---|
| Employee receives an advance | Within 30 days of when the expense is incurred |
| Employee substantiates the expense | Within 60 days after it was paid or incurred |
| Employee returns any excess | Within 120 days after the expense was paid or incurred |
| Periodic statement method | Employer sends a statement at least quarterly; employee returns or accounts for advances within 120 days of it |
Put these deadlines into the written policy and your expense tool's reminders. A common gap we see is a policy with no submission deadline at all, which makes the reasonable period test hard to meet.
What is the IRS mileage rate for 2026?
The IRS set the 2026 business standard mileage rate at 72.5 cents per mile, effective January 1, 2026, up 2.5 cents from 2025. It applies to gasoline, diesel, fully electric and hybrid vehicles. Publication 15 explains that when you reimburse by miles at no more than the federal rate, and the employee substantiates the business miles, the employee is treated as having accounted to you. Anything paid above the substantiated amount is reported as wages and taxed.
You don't have to pay the IRS rate. It's a tax safe harbor, not a federal pay mandate. But paying less can cause trouble under state reimbursement laws if it doesn't cover real costs, and under the FLSA for low-wage drivers. Some employers use a fixed-and-variable rate (FAVR) allowance instead; the IRS announcement points to Notice 2026-10 for the maximum vehicle cost used in those plans.
How are nonaccountable plan payments taxed?
A flat car allowance or an unsubstantiated phone stipend is a nonaccountable plan. Publication 463 says the employer combines these payments with wages and reports the total in box 1 of Form W-2. They're subject to federal income tax withholding, Social Security, Medicare and FUTA, and they feed into your deposit obligations under the rules in our guide to payroll tax deposit schedules.
Two traps catch employers:
- Reimbursing by reducing wages. Publication 463 treats an arrangement that repays expenses by reducing reported pay as nonaccountable, because the employee is entitled to their full pay either way.
- Assuming employees can deduct the rest. The IRS mileage announcement notes that taxpayers can't claim a miscellaneous itemized deduction for unreimbursed employee travel expenses (with narrow exceptions such as certain educators). A taxable stipend costs the employee more than it looks.
For nonexempt staff, overtime is the other angle. Under 29 CFR 778.217, true reimbursements that reasonably approximate the expense stay out of the regular rate, but a "reimbursement" that's disproportionately large gets the excess counted. See our guide to the FLSA regular rate for how that changes overtime pay.
Which states require employers to reimburse expenses?
These four state rules are checked against the statute text. Other states have similar laws, so check each state where you have employees.
| State | Statute | Core rule |
|---|---|---|
| California | Labor Code 2802 | Indemnify employees for all necessary expenditures or losses incurred in direct consequence of their duties. Awards carry interest, and "necessary expenditures" include all reasonable costs, including attorney's fees to enforce the right. |
| Illinois | 820 ILCS 115/9.5 | Reimburse necessary expenditures or losses. Employees submit within 30 calendar days unless the employer allows more time. A written policy can set limits, but not a policy of no or de minimis reimbursement. |
| Iowa | Iowa Code 91A.3(6) | Reimburse employer-authorized expenses in advance or within 30 days after the employee submits a claim. Refusals must be justified in writing. |
| New Hampshire | RSA 275:57 | Reimburse expenses paid at the employer's request within 30 days of proof of payment, except costs normally borne as a precondition of employment. |
California is the broadest. Labor Code 2802 turns on whether the expense was necessary, not whether you approved it in advance. Iowa, by contrast, covers expenses the employer authorized. When people work in several states, put expense policy on the same compliance map you use for multi-state payroll and conflicting tax rules.
Do you have to pay for remote workers' phones and internet?
Federal tax law doesn't require it. Some state laws do. In a 2014 decision involving Schwan's Home Service, the California Court of Appeal held that when employees must use personal cell phones for work calls, the employer owes a reasonable percentage of the bill, even on an unlimited plan where the employee's cost didn't go up. Many employers apply the same thinking to home internet when remote work is required.
A practical setup for remote and hybrid staff:
- Decide what's required. Required phones, internet or equipment are far more likely to be reimbursable necessary expenses.
- Choose accountable or taxable. A flat stipend is simple but taxable. A substantiated reimbursement (the bill plus a stated business use percentage) can be tax free.
- Set amounts by state. A stipend that's fine elsewhere can fall short of California's "all reasonable costs" standard.
- Write it down. Illinois gives a written policy real weight, and your accountable plan needs one anyway.
Our guide to managing a remote workforce legally in the US covers other obligations that follow remote staff across state lines.
How can unreimbursed expenses violate minimum wage law?
The FLSA requires wages to be paid "free and clear." Under the DOL regulation at 29 CFR 531.35, the wage requirement isn't met when an employee kicks back part of their wages to the employer, directly or indirectly. The regulation's own example: if you require employees to supply tools of the trade, there's a violation in any workweek where those costs cut into required minimum or overtime wages.
This matters most for drivers, field technicians and hourly remote staff paid near minimum wage. A delivery driver at the federal minimum who uses a personal car with no mileage reimbursement can fall below the minimum once vehicle costs come out. Check for these shortfalls yourself before a DOL wage and hour investigation does it for you.
A worked example
Take a hypothetical 300-person distributor with sales reps in California, Illinois and Texas who use personal cars and phones. Each rep gets a flat 400 dollar monthly car allowance and nothing for phones. Here's how the fix plays out:
- Tax status. The flat allowance is nonaccountable, so payroll confirms it's in box 1 and subject to withholding until the change.
- Switch to accountable mileage. Reps log business miles in the expense tool within 60 days, and the company pays 72.5 cents per mile. Those reimbursements are tax free.
- Phones. Phone use is required, so the company pays a stated business percentage of each bill in all three states, for consistency.
- Illinois policy. The written policy states the submission window and spending limits, with no category set to zero.
Common mistakes
- Calling a flat stipend "reimbursement" and leaving it off the W-2.
- No submission deadline, so the plan struggles to meet the reasonable period test.
- Ignoring phones and internet for required remote work in California.
- Letting tool or vehicle costs push hourly pay below minimum wage.
FAQ
Is the IRS mileage rate mandatory for employers?
No. Federal law doesn't require you to pay mileage at the IRS rate. The rate is a safe harbor: substantiated reimbursements up to it are tax free under an accountable plan. State laws such as California Labor Code 2802 can require you to cover actual reasonable costs, and the FLSA can require enough to keep pay at or above minimum wage.
Can a stipend be part of an accountable plan?
Only if employees substantiate their expenses and return any excess. A fixed monthly amount paid regardless of what people actually spend is nonaccountable and taxable. A common middle ground is a capped reimbursement: employees submit the bill and their business use percentage, and you pay the documented amount up to a stated limit.
How long do employees have to submit receipts?
For the IRS safe harbor, employees should substantiate within 60 days after the expense. Illinois sets a 30 calendar day submission window unless your policy allows more time. Use whichever window is shorter where both apply, put it in the written policy, and send automatic reminders so people don't miss it.
What to do next
- List every allowance and stipend you pay and label each one accountable or nonaccountable.
- Add 60 day substantiation and 120 day return deadlines to the written policy and your expense tool.
- Update mileage to the 2026 rate if you reimburse at the IRS rate.
- Map reimbursement statutes for every state where you have employees, and check that required costs never push hourly pay below minimum wage.
Sources
- Publication 463: Travel, Gift, and Car Expenses, Internal Revenue Service
- Publication 15 (Circular E), Employer's Tax Guide, Internal Revenue Service
- IRS sets 2026 business standard mileage rate at 72.5 cents per mile, Internal Revenue Service
- 29 CFR 531.35: "Free and clear" payment; "kickbacks", Legal Information Institute
Last reviewed: October 2026.

Comments
Post a Comment